In the blood

On my blood pledge thread against Jehovah’s Witness dogma someone has suggested that I am doing it in spite and it is about me not the cause. In case anyone else thinks those are my motives I show below my response to that charge. 

If it is about me, it is about a ten year old boy so committed to Jehovah that he could quote scripture looking at adults straight in the eye and say he was prepared to die for this belief. A ten year old that would later discover what a fraud the Jehovah’s Witness movement has been in its history when reading the original publications.

And yes as an adult there is something to be said for breaking a taboo that has no bad consequences for my body. I can give blood and it will cost me a minor inconvenience. I will replenish it myself. But to someone else that blood could make all the difference to their life. Now I am not just trying to encourage giving blood. I am about promoting and raising consciousness. It is not my fault that yours cannot be raised any further than it is.

I am echoing Hitchens remark that religion really does poison everything. The charitable giving of something that could save a life is suddenly taken by a group to be against God’s word – though it never occurred to the Israelites that blood of humans could be used to save another life, nor to the early christians. If you believe a parent has the right to refuse knowing the child in all probability will die as a result then I say with no respect you are lacking in the human instinct to go through hell to keep your children safe, and you deserve as much respect for that opinion as one that thinks suicide bombers have a point when they blow themselves and innocent bystanders up.

The children are innocent bystanders, who may like me reach the age of making their own choices and leave. All the kids I grew up in that Kingdom Hall did leave – children of Elders and Ministerial Servants. Yet if their parents had made the decision not to give them blood they never would have grown up to make that choice.If you fail to understand that, what my pledge is about, nor what my blog comments on, then all I can say is that is not my problem, I do not need you to sign the pledge.

Because if you think this is not an issue involving the labelling of children and indoctrination of children then really you do not understand RDFRS, you do not understand Richard Dawkins and if they cannot help you understand the issue it is not my problem.

Advertisements

Leave a comment

Filed under Jehovah's Witnesses, OUT campaign

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s