#NotAnotherBrother Quilliam Video and the Maajid Nawaz Article In The Guardian

Embedded image permalink

Quilliam have produced a new video, using the hashtag #notanotherbrother. As the blog site for the video states:

Daesh are radicalising our brothers to fight in Syria. They are tearing families apart. Enough is enough. Sharing this film will show Daesh that their extremist views have no place in our community. No family should lose another loved one to such hatred.

Not another child. Not another sister.


The video shows an ISIS fighter reading the letter sent by his brother back home. The brother narrates the letter he sent, with regret and anguish that his words encouraged his brother to start down the path of joining ISIS. The video ends with the caption:

Don’t let your words turn our brothers into weapons

The message reminded me of the song by the Aha singer Morten Harket, “Brother”, which he wrote after reading Maajid Nawaz’s book “Radical.”

You get more of a sense of what Quilliam and Maajid Nawaz are about in countering extremism in the above videos than reading The Guardian profile piece Maajid Nawaz: how a former Islamist became David Cameron’s anti-extremism adviser. It is an article with flaws in how it presents Maajid Nawaz’s views (which he has rebutted in full here), but a quote here by Nawaz is worth repeating:

“You don’t have to support violence to subscribe to certain intolerant ideas which create a climate in which extremists can flourish … Ideas – like those of the despicable far right – which privilege one identity to the detriment of the rights and freedoms of others.”

That message gets lost by looking to shoot the messenger. Never mind that Quilliam is a policy think tank – it gets compared with a grass roots organisation. Maajid Nawaz is no pious muslim – well he is not looking to pass a religious test for being a religious leader or a prophet for muslims. There are too many peacocks adorning themselves with the garb of pseudo religious integrity as it is.

Regarding the anonymous source “If you talk to people who went to school with him, they all say the same thing: they say it’s not about the mission or the cause, it’s about the man. I don’t think Maajid believes anything. I think he’s basically a man who says: what is my cause and what is going to get me the most attention, the most publicity?” I have heard a variation of that before spoken directly to me. In short, I do not think this was made up by the journalist.

It does though beg the question – why not speak to the people that went to school with him? I have regarding college – and I encouraged them to create their own blog post to talk about it. The answer I suspect, is because there is no relevance to his schoolboy days in heading a think tank in his 30s.

What is relevant, that Maajid Nawaz changed his conviction on religious political extremism. Wanted to make amends for the torture, and death, that the ideology inspired to happen in its name. One that he may have added to. If you read “Radical” that comes over – it is not an easy thing to live with knowing that your words and actions inspired others to do terrible things, and may have led to their own torture and death.

Which brings us to that #notanotherbrother video that captures both that and the remorse that follows. If you want to know the motivation behind such videos, read “Radical.” Rather than a cheap profile by someone who stiffs the drinks bill to the person better placed than most to talk about how Islamist extremism works.

Article written by John Sargeant on Homo economicus’ Weblog

Follow @JPSargeant78

Facebook: John Sargeant

My Huffington Post Blog

Email: JSargeant78@gmail.com

1 Comment

Filed under Uncategorized

One response to “#NotAnotherBrother Quilliam Video and the Maajid Nawaz Article In The Guardian

  1. Pingback: “Islam and The Future Of Tolerance” and Sam Harris on Profiling | Homo economicus' Weblog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s